Roth IRA vs traditional IRA, side by side
| Roth IRA | Traditional IRA | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax break | Withdrawals tax-free | Deduction now (if eligible) |
| 2026 limit | $7,500 combined, $8,600 at 50+ | |
| Income limit | $153k–$168k single | None to contribute; deduction limits if you have a work plan |
| Required withdrawals | None for the owner | From 73 (75 if born 1960 or later) |
| Early access | Contributions any time | 10% tax before 59½ |
Three examples
Each one puts $7,500 a year in for 30 years at 7%, and invests the traditional IRA's tax savings.
A 25-year-old in the 12% bracket
Expecting 22% in retirement. The Roth ends near $758,000, all spendable. The traditional IRA leaves about $591,000 after tax plus $75,000 in the side account: $666,000. The Roth wins by about $92,000.
Same tax rate now and later (22%)
You might expect a tie. The Roth still wins by about $30,000 because the traditional IRA's tax savings sit in a taxable account, where returns are taxed every year. The Roth shelters more money from day one.
A high earner in the 24% bracket, expecting 12% later
Here the traditional IRA wins: about $667,000 after tax plus $149,000 invested, or $817,000, against $758,000 for the Roth. A $58,000 edge, as long as the tax savings really get invested.
What's hard to model
- Future tax law. Today's brackets were made permanent in 2025, but Congress can change them.
- Required minimum distributions. Traditional IRA withdrawals from 73 can push Social Security into being taxable and raise Medicare premiums. A Roth avoids both.
- Heirs. Roth money passes to children tax-free; inherited traditional IRA money is taxed at their rate, often in peak earning years.
- Flexibility. Roth contributions can come out at any time with no tax or penalty, which makes a Roth a backup emergency fund. See the withdrawal calculator.
Already have a traditional IRA? The Roth conversion calculator shows what moving it would cost.
Traditional IRA vs Roth IRA: how to choose
- Lean Roth if you're early in your career, in the 10–12% bracket, or expect higher income later. Teens with their first job are ideal; see Roth IRA for kids.
- Lean traditional if you're in the 24% bracket or above now and expect to retire on much less, and you can deduct the contribution.
- Split it if you're unsure. The IRA vs Roth IRA choice doesn't have to be all or nothing; the $7,500 limit can be shared between them.
Not sure you qualify? Check the Roth IRA income limits or read what is a Roth IRA.